News Summary
A study reveals unintended consequences of Yelp’s ‘Black-owned’ tag in Detroit. Following its introduction, Black-owned restaurants saw a decline in average star ratings despite increased visibility. The research indicates that reviews from users aware of racial ownership often resulted in lower ratings. This phenomenon highlights the complexities of consumer perceptions and racial dynamics within digital platforms, raising questions about the effectiveness of initiatives aimed at supporting diversity in the restaurant industry.
Detroit has seen unintended consequences arising from the introduction of a new feature on Yelp designed to highlight Black-owned restaurants. A recent study found that these businesses experienced a decline in their average star ratings following the rollout of a “Black-owned” tag in 2020. This development raises questions about the effects of visibility on consumer perception and the complexities of racial dynamics within digital platforms.
The research analyzed over 250,000 Yelp reviews from both Black- and non-Black-owned restaurants in Detroit, revealing that reviews acknowledging Black ownership resulted in lower ratings. Specifically, restaurants identified as Black-owned received an average rating of 3.03 stars from users who were aware of this status. In comparison, those who were unaware awarded these establishments higher ratings, averaging 3.78 stars. This discrepancy appears to stem from an influx of reviews from users who were conscious of the business’s racial ownership, which negatively impacted overall ratings.
After the tag’s introduction, Black-owned restaurants saw a short-term spike in review activity; however, their average star rating fell from 3.91 to 3.88. Meanwhile, non-Black-owned establishments maintained a steady rating of 3.90 during the same period. While the decline in ratings may seem minor, even small changes can significantly affect a restaurant’s clientele and revenue, especially in a competitive market.
Yelp’s user base is predominantly white, educated, and affluent, which may contribute to biased perceptions noted in reviews. Some non-Black reviewers commented on experiences described as “slower” or “rude” service, potentially reflecting deeper cultural misunderstandings that arise from increased proximity to different communities. Additionally, businesses that do not choose to actively display the Black-owned tag can still be identified through user reviews and search results, leaving them without an option to opt out of this visibility.
The study’s findings also highlight broader issues facing Black entrepreneurs. The COVID-19 pandemic disproportionately affected Black-owned restaurants in Detroit, which experienced a significant loss of business compared to those where ownership information was not disclosed. Despite the launch of the tag increasing awareness of Black ownership in reviews by 4.3% within a year, the negative impact on star ratings has prompted a reevaluation of the utility of such digital interventions.
The evidence collected from the Yelp platform illustrates how the newfound visibility of Black-owned businesses may inadvertently reinforce existing inequalities in business exposure and access. Furthermore, Black-owned businesses often face greater challenges in securing loans and are significantly underrepresented in Michigan’s marketplace, exacerbating the difficulties they encounter.
These findings underline the complexity of racial dynamics and consumer behavior on digital platforms like Yelp. The notion that digital visibility is universally advantageous has proven to be misleading, with significant unintended consequences that can hinder the success of Black-owned restaurants in Detroit. As the restaurant industry continues to evolve alongside technological advancements, further research and discussion are warranted to better understand and mitigate the negative effects of initiatives aimed at enhancing diversity and visibility in the marketplace.
Deeper Dive: News & Info About This Topic
HERE Resources
Detroit to Celebrate Juneteenth with Community Events
Nominations Open for Best Brewery in Metro Detroit
Midtown Detroit Emerges as a Culinary Hotspot
Baseball Season Begins with Tigers’ Opening Day Festivities
Springing into Flavor: New Dining Hotspots in Detroit
Additional Resources
- Michigan Advance
- Wikipedia: Black-owned business
- The Conversation
- Google Search: Yelp impact on Black-owned restaurants
- Black Enterprise
- Google Scholar: Black-owned restaurants ratings
- Second Wave Media
- Encyclopedia Britannica: Restaurant industry
- Metro Times
- Google News: Impact of visibility on Black-owned businesses
Author: STAFF HERE DETROITMI WRITER
DETROIT STAFF WRITER The DETROIT STAFF WRITER represents the experienced team at HEREDetroitMI.com, your go-to source for actionable local news and information in Detroit, Wayne County, and beyond. Specializing in "news you can use," we cover essential topics like product reviews for personal and business needs, local business directories, politics, real estate trends, neighborhood insights, and state news affecting the area—with deep expertise drawn from years of dedicated reporting and strong community input, including local press releases and business updates. We deliver top reporting on high-value events such as Movement Electronic Music Festival, Detroit Grand Prix, and America's Thanksgiving Parade. Our coverage extends to key organizations like the Detroit Regional Chamber and Focus HOPE, plus leading businesses in automotive and healthcare that power the local economy such as General Motors, Ford Motor Company, and Henry Ford Health. As part of the broader HERE network, including HEREGrandRapids.com, HERENorthville.com, HERENovi.com, and HEREPlymouth.com, we provide comprehensive, credible insights into Michigan's dynamic landscape.
